Go With Your Gut
That is what this blog post really should be called but I started this whole "Part 1" thing so I'll keep it going till this room is parted out. You know the saying "you have to kiss a lot of frogs before you find your prince?" I think this applies to how many times we redid this cabinet and we ended up with the prince in the end but we could have had him in the beginning!The next big thing we needed to tackle in the dining room was the built-in china cabinet. It was dark, stain and trim didn't match what we are slowly replacing throughout the house and the hardware was hideous. Please ignore my poor reflection selfie as I show you how bad this is.
I struggled with what I wanted to do here. naturally I took to Photoshop and did some quick options I thought may work. My gut was telling me to do a mix of white gloss paint and dark stain but I wasn't sure. (See bottom row). The only thing I was certain on was the new hardware. We splurged big on these at Neu's Hardware. Seeing we only needed 3 small and 3 large pulls, we could stomach the cost but anyone doing an entire kitchen in these must be, as NeNe Leakes says, "I'm very rich."
My gut said do it but my heart was thinking I was just going with that because that is always the combo I like. Many things in the house were already wood and white. So second guessing myself, I scrapped all this and thought maybe an overall color was best? And then do I maybe put fabric in back to add interest and brightness in back? Meanwhile, the demo began on the cabinet to see if we could sand down the doors.
After sanding down the doors we realized the grain of the wood was really deep and we couldn't get them to smooth out and not knowing if I would be painting them or staining them, we needed a flat surface to work with. So we had the (air quotes) "brilliant" idea to add a wood veneer to the fronts.
Once the veneers were finished I started looking at colors and fabrics.
I settled on a grayish blue paint and a geometric wood grain printed fabric designed by a local artist I found at a buy local craft fair. I sanded and painted the frame of the built in first and then stained the upper cabinet shelves and inside upper cabinet walls the new stain color and then contact papered the lower shelves with a dark woodgrain paper. This all went easy. A little too easy.
Next up with determining where the hardware would go and drill all those holes so I could sand down the drawers and doors before I painted them. Cue the painters tape. I knew I didn't want the handles at the end of the cabinet door like the previous ones were. These were too hefty for that plus I wanted these to feel as if they were original to the period and I have seen some credenzas with centered handles. In the middle of the door felt right but I wasn't sure if I wanted the handles dead-center or up higher so I had to map it out. Dead-center it was. Originally, silly us, we measures the holes of the hardware and marked them all centered with each surface. After drilling the holes we did a test fit and because these handles flare out, they cast a deep shadow. This shadow gave the illusion like they were sitting too low on the cabinet face even though they were centered perfectly. Ugh! So we filled the holes and redrilled before I painted.
Ok, with that out of the way, now for the rest to be painted. First drawer done. Looked great! So great that I don't even think it was dry yet before I tested it in the cabinet and attached the pull.
The paint dried a little rough so I lightly sanded it and did one more coat and was going to let that dry overnight while I started the others. The next day I found the veneer was bubbled and rippled and awful. What I learned from this is that veneer is an art and a skill and my husband and I aren't meant for it.
After this failed attempt, the original wood wasn't really usable anymore. We decided to try MDF. We see it used on home shows all the time, sure, why not right? We have learned that MDF is an art and a skill and my husband and I aren't meant for it. The exposed edges can't be painted directly so I didn't do that and when in the cabinet they looked horrible. So bad I don't think I even took pictures of that. We weren't about to veneer the edges to paint them so we trashed those. Note to self: Buy stock in Lowe's.
Meanwhile, some time passed. We were both frustrated with it. Maybe this was all a good thing because the more I looked at it the more I went back to my original thought of dark stain and gloss white. But I was concerned it may look too chess board black and white. Then it hit me. What if the inside was the dark stain, the trim was also the dark stain but the doors were more the Brazilian Walnut to match the floors.
So that is what I did. We bought pieces of poplar wood and my husband cut all new faces. We also decided to move up the hardware a bit more in the process too.
Last thing left to do was to decorate it. This probably took as long as it took to redo the cabinet. I have a lot of vintage pieces I collect. I have loads of Candlewick glassware, a lot of cake stands, a bunch of Cathrineholm enamelware, some Russel Wright pottery and some other misc things and not everything could make the cut. I didn't want it cluttered up so only my favs made the trip to the glass door uppers and the rest I either stored down below with platters and everyday things or I parted with them.
And there she is.